During the last twelve months, the NCAA has arguably received the closest scrutiny ever regarding student-athlete recruiting and extra-benefit scandals costing prominent, successful football and basketball coaches at powerful universities their jobs (Jim Tressel Ohio State & Bruce Pearl Univ. of Tenn), seemingly endless (proposed or actual) conference re-alignments and discussions that appear to disregard the ethics of amateurism in order to satisfy an insatiable appetite for lucrative television revenues, and allegations of major recruiting violations and embarrassingly low graduation rates that taint the accomplishments of the two 2010 BCS championship teams (Auburn graduated exactly 0 of their African-african american athletes!).
Such negative publicity has increased the assault on the NCAA as the sole arbitrator of major college athletics, which is driven by a wide range of critics, including scholars, the media, state legislators, Congress, the courts, U.S. Secretary of Education Arnie Duncan and even President Barack Obama. As a result, the NCAA has once again discussed introducing surface “reforms” that hardly substantially address the situation such as increasing “full” scholarship amounts by $2000.00.
After extensive qualitative study of the literature, the law, NCAA rules and policies, court cases, interviews with former and current major college student-athletes, and my personal experiences as a former D-1 football player at the University of oklahoma. I am convinced that the NCAA governance system is fundamentally flawed and divorced from the realities of today’s collegiate landscape. Further, the NCAA’s own rules and policies, and/or the lack of enforcement thereof, actually undermine their own antiquated ideals of “amateurism” and “student-athlete” expressed in the NCAA’s mission and core values. In fact, I argue that the NCAA itself substantially interfere with the ability of student-athletes to holistically
develop and fully prosper in the current collegiate model of athletics.
The NCAA must significantly reform its policies and rules in order to improve its student-athletes’ academic performance, life skills development, economic opportunities, and graduation rates. Therefore, I propose a number of specific new
policies and rules for careful consideration and adoption by the NCAA, including without limitation the following:
- Extend athletic scholarships for greater than the five-year undergraduate period;
- Increase the amounts of athletic scholarships to cover all living and student expenses since there is no time for outside employment;
- Require each school to have the same ratio of academic coaches to student-athletes as it has athletic coaches to student-athletes in each
- Require that the academic personnel working with student-athletes not
be athletic department employees;
- Enlarge amounts of athletic scholarships to cover all living and student expenses, WITHOUT ANY ARBITRARY CAP;
- Provide life-time injury and disability benefits for student-athletes injured while participating in their sport;
- Allow student-athletes to take personal advantage of their own
- Provide student-athletes with an equitable share of the revenue produced by their participation within their sport.
Without a doubt, There are substantial legal, equitable, financial, academic, and socio-cultural reasons for each proposed new policy and rule to implemented immediately.